MY KITCHEN RULES drama heats up as ‘Plate Gate’ hits the table

- Advertisement -

Latest

- Advertisement -

Share

My Kitchen Rules is turning up the drama in its second week, with tonight’s dinner set to bring another round of tensions, opinions and divided diners to the table.

Seven is enjoying a strong start to the new season, with MKR delivering its biggest launch episode in seven years, while the series has already delivered walkouts and clashes as Alisha and Deanne face scrutiny over their menu and choice of crockery.

Krysten appears less than impressed as Alisha and Deanne’s choice of crockery becomes the focus of the latest MKR table debate (image – Seven)


Supplied:

- Advertisement -


Chaotic, brash and full of energy, South Australian “classy bogans” Alisha and Deanne are out to prove their critics wrong when their MKR instant restaurant, Hot Mess, opens Monday night on Seven and 7plus.

The best friends are banking on big flavours and hearty dishes to win over judges Manu Feildel and Colin Fassnidge. But while they’re busy cooking, tensions at the table keep simmering.

“I’m expecting crazy vibes,” says food stylist Jane, who hopes the pair will keep their plating simple and elegant.

Then the melamine plates hit the dining table.

The simmering debate over taste versus presentation boils over as the table weighs in on the girls’ choice of crockery. Will Alisha and Deanne’s food speak for itself, or will Plate Gate overshadow their menu and scores?

My Kitchen Rules continues tonight, Monday 5 October at 7.30pm on Seven and 7plus.

- Advertisement -


Know more about this or another Australian media story?

Call/Text 0428 275 111 or use the contact button below.

Kyle Laidlaw
Kyle Laidlaw
Co-Owner and News Editor at TV Blackbox, Kyle Laidlaw is an avid media enthusiast with over 10 years of experience. Kyle regularly follows all things TV related, both in Australia and overseas with a particular interest in local free-to-air scheduling and new show commissions.
Comments

175 COMMENTS

    • Romulus Romeo im looking forward to see Jane and Shane cook there perfect just ask them this show has to be scripted

      • Yeah, it looks they will be cooking last so we’ll have to wait to next week. The next two cooks in Melbourne will be interesting.

  1. Um – aren’t they eating the food and not the crockery?
    Jane needs to get a grip (as well as removing that very large pole from her scrawny arse)🙄

  2. If they had just had plain white crockery with maybe a small dainty pattern if they wanted. But all round a great effort as the show is for Home Cooks isn’t it

    • Lesley Cooke no. Undercooked scallops are dangerous. They wasted so much lamb it is a disgrace. They knew they’d have to cook enough to be able to choice the best. Real home cooks are better than that. Plus have you ever read the name of the show? It is my kitchen RULES, not just average. That means someone has to excell.
      If the scallops had been cooked properly and they hadn’t wasted so much lamb, it would have shown some skills.

      • Shirley Mulhern remember they have families so they would of put the rest of the meat in the fridge so no wastage that’s what i would do

      • Shirley Mulhern some have who had been on MKR to did fails in their cooking as from raw, undercooked and overcooked… them cooks also deemed themselves as well above average homecooks-chefs.

    • Lesley Cooke home cooked still means nicely presented – if they tried to make it all “trashy” they certainly succeeded

    • Lesley Cooke .. they had melamine crockery not even proper plates. It’s not a picnic it’s a dinner .. I was shocked actually. Yeah ok they classify themselves as bogans, but there is a line that really shouldn’t be crossed. Have a little class. How embarrassing.

  3. Jane and what a ‘Shame’ are an absolute disgrace, they are so rude it’s a pity she doesn’t have a word with her Hairdresser she could do so much more with that hair, an actual style may help. And to be honest I think the Girls Food looked delicious the only mistake was not serving Cream or Ice-Cream with the Sticky Date… I nearly spat out my Drink when I saw the Cutlery they gave Jane!! GOLD! 😂😂

  4. To be honest I was more upset with judge Colin’s sarcastic comment mentioning the word Acid in his comments. To me it was rubbing it into the girls faces

    • Pam Seuren yes I was to. I think Colin and Manu are stirring trouble. They should have spoke up last night and stated ” we are judging food not plates etc “

      • Margaret Bonacina yes they are awful once again home cooks I remember a few seasons ago a couple of lads had no idea how to present food but it tasted good these things obviously come with experience but the judges certainly stir the pot show needs a long rest

      • Trish Neads oh ffs get over yourself! theyre dealing with immature adults supposedly cooking in a comp! Manu & Colin cant control the misfits that are chosen out of nominations for the show. Bedsides they take it all in absorb and remember it all then when the time is right they ‘catch’ them out and say it in front of all the team

      • Beck Wade I’m Aussie born and bred and to me it was pure shit stirring and sarcasm from Colin. There is an old saying that sarcasm is the lowest form of Witt

      • Beck Wade Colin has nothing to be joking about , recently pled guilty to driving under the influence of cocaine for the 2nd time. These so called TV celebrities are overeating themselves.

    • Pam Seuren I agree .. and I don’t like the little smiles he directs at Jane when the girls say something … I think she was put in there as a set-up seeing she & Colin are friends 😤

      • Gary Ashton that doesn’t mean you have to keep rubbing it into her face. It might have been ok to correct her once but not to keep bringing the word up all the time

      • Pam Seuren Awww diddums really!! lighten up lady!!…Its not me that was rubbing in her face..I dont recall being on the show ..dopey Get a sense of humour I didnt ask for your stupid comment !!

    • Pam Seuren yes, he has made a couple of snide comments, that sarcastic smirk and then buys them flowers. I don’t like the vibes that I’m getting.

    • Pam Seuren no , she was wrong , she was told she was wrong but just kept doubling down , she made herself look stupid

    • Pam Seuren Yes I Agree with you he is ruling it in every chance he gets I a. Not a fan off Colin this year ,
      And if the Judge’s do not pull Jane up on the way she Specken to the other Contestants I am done with Show .

  5. I was hoping they’d do well but I gotta say im sick of her “we’re just gonna show em we can cook” i just wanted her to shut up & cook instead of playing up to the camera

    • Margaret Moffat think they need new judges. Collin especially needs to be replace. For me he is too full of himself

      • Jeny Chandler Absolutely Agree they are Judges Not there to Laugh and use silly words it certainly turns one off watching it 😉

  6. Colin need to be kicked off the show
    His bias
    He plays favourites
    His arrogant
    His sarcastic
    His an all round DOG BASTARD

      • Claire Thompson well they did. Are you going to sit there all day and comment on everyone’s post that didn’t like the plates?

    • Vivienne Pateman note the name of their Kitchen…
      “Hot Mess”… plastic plates fit their decor, they did up it with silver cutlery and glasses😁

      • Vivienne Pateman right-correct you may be, but them plates still fit their Kitchen name “Hot Mess”… They did up it some with them melamine plates, at least they were not them white paper or those plastic BBQ ones.🤭

      • Vivienne Pateman stfu Jane. U sound like her .
        Get ya head out of your backside ..the girls did an amazing job .I be lmao when stuffy Jane and controlled shane have to eat their words. Don’t answer i said what i said ..

      • Helen Barker I never once said the girls did not do a good job. I commented on the bloody plates. Have you made remarks on everyone’s posts about the plates or just decided to pick me out. I don’t care if you call me Jane I’m not into calling people names but whatever floats your boat.

    • Vivienne Pateman so what i have similar plates that are ceramic and Arabian in design. My food still tastes the same as if on a white plate. I find plane white plates are for people with vanilla personalities

      • Jenny Murray and good for you. My opinion. Are you having a go at everyone that didn’t like the plates or just me. By the way I never once said I’d prefer white plates, so next time you want to try and have a go at someone’s personality maybe read what their actual comment was first.

  7. It’s definitely not a Master Chef competition where amateur cooks go on to bigger and better things to boast the passion of cooking no no MKR definitely dosen’t do any of those things in fact ever since Fassnidge joined MKR the entire show is plummeting in a down ward motion and Fassnidge should be removed from the show as he was charged with a cocane related offence whilst under going a random breath and drug roadside test definitely not a good reputation to hold as he is a qualified chef and restaurant owner him self

  8. They did it their way, the plates are what they are…..colourful personalities, its not Master chef.
    This is why I like MKR

  9. I thought buying the girls flowers was a kick in the face for other contestants. Maybe they all need to get stroppy and walk off then they might get flowers too.😅

    • Linda Mace classy choice… I would have been real peeved off if them crockery were them white plastic or paper BBQ plates!!!!
      LOL

    • Nicole Ioannou get real!!! beautiful food has been served on banana leaves, BBQ paper plates, wooden boards, flat rocks, even eaten directly from its cooking vessel…. etc

      If it can feed a hungry person who cares what it is served on.
      .

      • Nicole Ioannou sorry it’s not all a “have too” world, rightly people have their own perceived expectations, but then again!!! it ain’t a “have too” neither a “need too”… one could serve at a dinner party, food on a banana leaf, on a wooden board, flat stones or just eat a communal dinner party meal from one big dish with just their clean hands.😊

      • Kathy Hamblin you do you
        Btw boards, leaves and flat stone are generally pattern free and have a place at a dinner party
        But if “ day of the dead” is your vibe … yay for you

      • Nicole Ioannou Thank you, so much… I thought you would see it my way eventually…
        The “day of the dead” reads more like your own vibe than mine…
        Need a set of 12 shovels? 😊

      • Nicole Ioannou this is what you missed out on… by not saying
        “Yes Please”

        ◆ Serving Platters
        6X2 Tableware Plate Frosted Imitation Porcelain Shovels…
        Sold by: Vevipipo

        I take them 2 last pics are your selfies.. the last one especially, I have to say, you are artistic with your make-up.❤️

  10. I think the melamine mismatched plates were all part of their “hot mess” restaurant – and a little bit to rub it in the face of Jane who they must have know would have a hissy fit over the plates. Personally, I was not a fan of plates – but they are not there to judge the plates – and I have to say, the food looked pretty good. It’s my guess if they get to cook again, they might do things differently

  11. beautiful food or not has been served on banana leaves, BBQ paper plates, wooden boards, flat rocks, even eaten directly from its cooking vessel…. etc

    If it can feed a hungry person who cares what it is served on.

    • Kathy Hamblin get over yourself. Nobody cares about where you pretend you’ve been.
      I donate to feed the homeless every two weeks!! I bet you dont. The plate was too small, get over it..

      • David John hmmm
        That very comment of yours, reflects more on you then it would on me.

        Nothing for me to get over, there are no hurdles here to jump, just ALL opinions said by many.

        You do really care!!!, bless you, here you are responding, caring enough to assume about whereever I might have been, never did I mention any places, just what food could be served on.

        Most who don’t care, are smart enough to just scroll passed.

        Here you are, patting yourself on your own back on donating to the homeless and its twice a week…. Most do not go about seeking acknowledgement for their selfless and generous deeds, they prefer to do it in silence.

        Every two weeks! David!! may you be blest 7 fold, you wonderful, thoughtful person, David.

        God bless you.

        I am sure this every 2 weeks good deeds of yours, which you took time out of your day to let us all here know, especially for all those who read it.

        They may just feel this very selfless act, this very shared information here, totally about you, you yourself, by you, struck a cord on ones heart strings. You are just a great stand up kinda guy…so kind, in thought, deeds and words.

        A plate is a plate, remains just a plate until served with food upon it.

        Ps. sarcasm is best served on large plates😊

      • Kathy Hamblin wow! Are you a sick c#nt.
        Feel free to spew your retarded mental health issues in one Guinness book of pathetic nonsense for all to read, if anyone could be bothered. Sick little individual you are.

  12. They should be able to have what they want. This show has now become a joke and I am starting to dislike both Manu and Colin for letting it get this way. They must really need the money

  13. It’s supposed to be about cooking and people who want to have a go as to the other 2 who are there to just taste and not eat they should be thrown out I hope they fail big time when they cook

  14. thought last night was hilarious seeing Jane’s face when the meals came out on colourful plastic plates
    Was abit disappointed with the dessert. I had sticky date pudding many times and it’s always been served with icecream. Maybe the girls should of made the icecream

    • Suzi Waaga they made cream but chose not to add it. It was ready to be piped onto the plates. Could have put it seperately in a side dish if the dessert was too hot

      • Winny Rocco sad that they thought it unnecessary- I would find hat dessert far too sweet without the cream. Easily served in a side-pot.

      • Winny Rocco yes I wished they’d thought to add cream on the side given the sauce was warm. Basically though it was a nice menu. Jane is just a snob.

      • Louise Frodyma The entire world knows a sticky date is almost inedible without cream to temper the sweetness..they were incredibly stupid.

  15. I have stopped watching I find Colin to be a petty nasty average chef at best.This show was great once when it was about the food now it is just nasty.
    It will go the way of the Block completely Cringe TV not worth watching.

  16. Loved the plates, it’s about your kitchen and if that’s what they use good on them,I have white plates and lovely coloured ones to, and I think the taster woman and her partner shouldn’t be there as what I read he is a chef,can’t stand Colin

  17. I like that they didn’t use the plates Jane was expecting and I said to hubby if it was me I would of just put a teeny tiny bite of each bit of food on her plate given she apparently doesn’t eat she just tastes. I like the colourful restaurant it showed their personalities and the fact when things went wrong the ladies didn’t give up

    • I totally agree with you. I have been saying that all along, why waste good food on them. I would love to see how much the two of them eat when they are on their own. I’m so over the faces she pulls, going to be very interesting when it’s their turn to cook.

  18. Honestly I thought it was a home cooking show….Where does it say what sort of plates food is to be served on???
    Disgusting that people laugh at another person’s choice ….

  19. Food, not the plate it’s on. Since Jane is so caught up in presentation, perhaps she needs to look at how she looks……..her hair is disguting, it looks like she just comes it back and sticks it down. Looks horrible from the back, and those little whispy bits sticking out makes it look untidy. She does not present well

  20. Why don’t the two boof head judges put the issue to rest and simply repeat what they have said before in other series. They don’t really judge on presentation, only the taste and preparation of the food.
    Pretty obvious they set these disputes up. Picking contestants that are not likely to get along. So it’s not about home cooking anymore its about the drama.
    Jane is on the wrong show anyway, she needs to go to Master Chef!

  21. It’s starting to go down hill ,why can’t people be honest, put shit people on and watch your ratings drop 😡😡😡

  22. it’s bullshit. the plate was only mentioned early then they moved on until cocaine colin said to someone . “what about the plate” . He needs to go . the whole show is deteriorating day by day.., be glad when it’s finished.

  23. I wouldn’t use those plates myself but I wouldn’t make a fuss about it either, as long as my food arrives hot and good

  24. I couldn’t stop laughing last night what to hell, when the two women started cooking in the kitchen I had to turn the volume down they were doing my heading, and what’s with those plates when a plate is full on patent like that and all different colors yes it is hard to see the food on the plate and yes it looks much nicer and you can see the food on a white plate. I yes they are backyard home cooks personally I don’t think there that good enough to be on the show and I don’t think Jane and shame should be on the show, and I couldn’t understand all the shopping they do and they don’t use half to stuff all that back strap that they bought and cooked up why why so many pieces. And the sticky date well it wasn’t presented that nice I would have served a nice strawberries on top or some icing sugar and cream or ice cream on the side in a small bowl or jug I don’t think they really have a clue to be honest. The two girls are a real hot mess. And column smartass comment and he has become a smartass I used to like him but he’s changed and maybe he’s on too much acid. He’s a smart ass prick. And Jane should not be on the show at all you’re there to judge the food but she is too busy judging a plate or the surroundings. I thought it was a cooking show once upon a Time it used to be all about the food last night you could barely see the food on the patterned plates.

  25. Does anyone at the table ever pull up rude or disrespectful comments from diners at the table? Only see what is on the tv ads (which is enough for me to know I don’t want to watch). Did anyone say something to the crone about her “naive” comment to the young girl? Rude and unnecessary. Someone has tickets on themselves.

  26. Must say somewhat disappointed with Colin and Manu, egging on conversations and sitting back laughing. The show has become a slinging match.

  27. I think Colin and Manu are the professional judges on this show. Some of the contestants are bitchy….and it’s not just the women. 🤣

  28. Love love love everything about these girls .sassy. quirky .hot mess.
    Janes face was hilarious. Message to Jane you dont eat the plate
    20 yrs hospitality before I changed careers and bet u haven’t met that many famous chefs or really famous ppl .get your nose out of your own ass and pass your husband his balls back from your handbag..
    I love that the girls are loud and yes youre going to get alot of the contestants repeating same stuff.dont like it switch it off
    They did it their way how about the wingers on this post take your own advice and stfu
    Its about big personalities
    Ppl showing their home cooking skills
    Jane and Shane can be the 1st to leave .dont let the door hit them on the way out

  29. I would serve her a teaspoon of a portion on her plate and a glass of water to wash her mouth after tasting. I also feel the judges need to be a little more caring about the behavior and remarks at the table, they seem to encourage it, just for their own entertainment.

  30. Very disappointed in Manu and Colin thinking it is a joke with their smirks. Maybe Jane’s meal needed a little dose of epsom salts hidden in it

  31. Presentation and Atmosphere: Beyond taste, contestants are judged on how they present their food and their overall restaurant experience. This includes plating aesthetics, the “vibe” of their pop-up restaurant, and their service.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -

Latest Stories

Advertisement